According to a November 17 report by Shorebeat, the township’s proposed amended complaint says six candidates advanced through interviews before undergoing background investigations. All six were already serving as law enforcement officers elsewhere in New Jersey, but Toms River officials were subsequently informed that each had failed the checks.
The township alleges that Business Administrator Jonathan Salonis requested comprehensive explanations from Police Chief Guy Maire. According to the complaint, the initial response provided insufficient detail, and Maire later told the administration that the prosecutor’s office had directed him against providing additional information. That account remains an allegation in the township’s filing.
Toms River’s proposed complaint also raises questions about the rejection of female and minority applicants. It alleges that nearly all candidates from those groups were unsuccessful during this year’s hiring process. The report does not identify the applicants or establish why they were rejected.
The Ocean County Prosecutor’s Office disputes the legal basis for the township’s case and is asking the court to dismiss it. Its attorneys argue that prosecutors have broad supervisory authority over local police departments, including responsibilities involving confidential background investigations and sensitive law enforcement information.
The dispute also involves the questionnaire used to screen prospective Toms River police officers. Township officials contend that they should be permitted to revise it, while the prosecutor’s office maintains that its approval is required, according to the report.
The hiring allegations add another issue to an ongoing legal battle over authority within the Toms River Police Department. A judge is scheduled to hear arguments on December 4 concerning both the township’s request to amend its complaint and the prosecutor’s request to dismiss the lawsuit. The court has not ruled on the allegations described in the proposed amended complaint.